How much is your shop losing to missed supplements?
How much money is your body shop losing on missed supplements? Enter your claims a month, flagged dollars per claim and the share you expect to collect, and this free calculator gives your own monthly and yearly estimate. It starts at 15 claims a month, the $1,374 median flagged across 62 real Claim Audits, and an assumed 10% turning into money you would have missed. Change all three. This free calculator comes from Claimory, the all-in-one body shop management software for collision repair shops, and the Claimory AI Claim Audit checks a collision repair estimate for operations it appears to have left off before it goes to the insurance adjuster.
Your shop's numbers
Insurance claims your shop wrote last month. Leave out cash jobs.
The median across 62 real Claim Audits is $1,374, flagged and not collected. Use your own number once you have audited your own claims.
An assumption, not a measurement: flagged dollars that are real, that the carrier approves, and that you would not have caught anyway. Starts at 10%.
Estimated gap
$24,732
a year, at the share you set.
Estimate only, based on your inputs. See what Claim Audits find on real claims for where the $1,374 comes from and what it does not prove.
Check this on your own claims
The 14-day free trial needs no credit card and includes 3 Claim Audits, so your claims can replace these numbers.
What this number actually represents
This estimate starts from dollars Claim Audit flagged on real claims. A flagged dollar is not collected money: the carrier still decides, and some findings are items the estimator would have caught anyway, which is why the calculator applies a share. Missed supplements are usually not lost negotiations. They are line items that never got submitted, often because the teardown happened on a busy day or the estimator was pulled to another bay. A claim-management system with supplement aging surfaces them so the office manager can act on the oldest open items first.
Results vary by shop and by how consistently the team works the queue. The Claimory methodology shows the measured results, the sample behind them, and their limits.
Close the gap claim by claim in Claimory
The calculator gives one number for the whole shop. Inside Claimory, the Supplements tab on each claim shows what was requested, approved and still pending, and once a supplement is marked sent it counts the days it has waited on the insurance carrier.
On Professional and up, the Open Supplements panel on the dashboard lists every supplement still waiting on a carrier, longest wait first, with its claim number, carrier and amount. To find the lines that never got written, Professional and Elite shops run a Claim Audit on the estimate before it goes to the adjuster.

Supplement gap calculator questions
How does the supplement gap calculator work out its number?
The Claimory supplement gap calculator multiplies three inputs: claims a month, times flagged dollars per claim, times the share you expect to become money you would have missed. That is the monthly figure; times 12 is the yearly figure. Per claim is the monthly figure divided by claims a month.
Where does the $1,374 starting number come from?
$1,374 is the median dollar amount flagged and not collected across 62 real Claimory Claim Audits from 25 shops, measured on November 3, 2026. It is what the audits flagged, not what carriers paid. The Claimory methodology page lists how it was measured and what it does not prove.
Why does the calculator start at a 10% share?
The 10% share is an assumption, not a measurement: the part of flagged dollars that is real, that the carrier approves, and that the shop would not have caught anyway. Too few carrier decisions are logged to measure it yet, so the calculator labels it as an assumption and lets you set it from 1% to 50%.
What claims count toward claims per month?
Count the insurance claims your shop wrote last month and leave out cash jobs, since a cash job has no carrier to supplement. The calculator starts at 15 claims a month and takes 1 to 500.
How do I find my own flagged dollars per claim?
Audit your own estimates. Claimory's Claim Audit, included on Professional and Elite with 3 audits in the free trial, checks a collision repair estimate for operations and charges it appears to miss or underpay, ties each finding to an estimate line, photo or document on the claim, and puts a dollar value on it. Once a few of your own claims are audited, use their median in place of the starting number.
Replace the estimate with your own claims
Free 14-day trial, no credit card, 3 Claim Audits included.
No credit card. Works with CCC ONE and Mitchell.
