Skip to main content
    Prices go up on January 1, 2027. Subscribe before then and keep today's price. How the price lock works
    Claimory research

    What Claim Audits flag on collision repair estimates

    Across 62 claims at 25 collision repair shops, audited from January 23 to October 30, 2026, the item Claimory's Claim Audit flagged most on collision repair estimates was ADAS calibration, on 42 claims. The list below ranks every item it flagged on 10 or more of those claims.

    Finding types counted November 6, 2026, from the same audits Claimory measured on November 3, 2026, in Claimory's production data. Flagged dollars are what Claim Audit priced on a finding, not money a carrier paid.

    The items Claim Audit flagged most, by share of claims

    Open an item to see what it is and what a collision estimator checks before adding it to a supplement.

    1. ADAS calibration

      42 of 62 claims (68%)

      $250 median flagged per finding, from 36 findings with a dollar figure.

      About ADAS calibration: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      ADAS calibration resets the cameras, radar and sensors behind features like lane keeping, adaptive cruise and blind spot monitoring after a repair moves or replaces a part they mount to or see through.
      What the estimator checks
      The vehicle maker's calibration requirements for each part replaced or removed, and a calibration line, in-house or sublet, on the estimate.
    2. OEM parts and OEM repair procedures

      38 of 62 claims (61%)

      $137 median flagged per finding, from 51 findings with a dollar figure.

      About OEM parts and OEM repair procedures: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      An OEM finding covers a non-OEM or recycled part the shop should question, a missing disclosure for one, or a vehicle maker's repair procedure the estimate does not follow.
      What the estimator checks
      The part type on each line against the policy, any state parts disclosure rule, and the maker's repair procedure.
    3. Pre-repair and post-repair scans

      34 of 62 claims (55%)

      $66 median flagged per finding, from 48 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Pre-repair and post-repair scans: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      A pre-repair scan reads the vehicle's computer modules for fault codes before work starts, and a post-repair scan confirms the systems are clear before delivery. Some findings flag a scan priced at the wrong labor rate.
      What the estimator checks
      The maker's position on scans for the vehicle, and that each scan is priced at the right labor rate.
    4. Blending an adjacent panel

      32 of 62 claims (52%)

      $114 median flagged per finding, from 38 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Blending an adjacent panel: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Blending feathers new paint into the undamaged panel next to a refinished one, so the color matches across the gap.
      What the estimator checks
      The color match on each undamaged panel next to a refinished panel.
    5. Corrosion protection

      29 of 62 claims (47%)

      $46 median flagged per finding, from 18 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Corrosion protection: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Corrosion protection restores the coating on metal a repair exposes, such as cavity wax inside a replaced door shell.
      What the estimator checks
      The maker's corrosion protection steps for each replaced or repaired steel part.
    6. Labor or materials rate below the shop's posted rate

      27 of 62 claims (44%)

      $210 median flagged per finding, from 51 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Labor or materials rate below the shop's posted rate: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      A rate finding means the estimate pays body, paint or mechanical labor, or paint materials, below the rate the collision shop has posted.
      What the estimator checks
      Each rate on the estimate against the shop's posted rates.
    7. Seam sealer

      26 of 62 claims (42%)

      $45 median flagged per finding, from 21 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Seam sealer: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Seam sealer restores the factory seal along panel joints after a panel is replaced or a seam is opened.
      What the estimator checks
      The maker's seam sealer locations for each replaced panel.
    8. Remove and install (R&I) operations

      22 of 62 claims (35%)

      $56 median flagged per finding, from 33 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Remove and install (R&I) operations: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Remove and install (R&I) is the labor to take a part off and put it back so another part can be repaired or refinished, such as door glass, a mirror or a trim panel.
      What the estimator checks
      Every part that has to come off for the repair or refinish, matched to a line on the estimate.
    9. Weld-through primer

      21 of 62 claims (34%)

      $55 median flagged per finding, from 15 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Weld-through primer: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Weld-through primer protects bare metal at weld locations when a welded or structural panel is replaced or repaired.
      What the estimator checks
      The maker's weld and primer steps for each welded panel.
    10. Clips and one-time-use fasteners

      20 of 62 claims (32%)

      $35 median flagged per finding, from 13 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Clips and one-time-use fasteners: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Clips and one-time-use fasteners are the retainers that break, or that the maker says to replace, when a molding, panel or trim piece comes off.
      What the estimator checks
      The clips and fasteners the maker says to replace on each part removed.
    11. Feather, prime and block

      18 of 62 claims (29%)

      $65 median flagged per finding, from 13 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Feather, prime and block: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Feather, prime and block is the prep that smooths a repaired area and primes it before paint.
      What the estimator checks
      A prep line for each panel that is repaired rather than replaced.
    12. Hazardous waste disposal

      18 of 62 claims (29%)

      $24 median flagged per finding, from 10 findings with a dollar figure.

      About Hazardous waste disposal: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Hazardous waste disposal covers getting rid of paint, solvent and other regulated waste the repair produces.
      What the estimator checks
      Whether the shop's disposal cost is on the estimate.
    13. Color sand, de-nib and buff

      13 of 62 claims (21%)

      Too few of the 16 findings carried a dollar figure for a median.

      About Color sand, de-nib and buff: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      Color sand, de-nib and buff removes dust and texture from fresh clear coat so the finish matches the rest of the vehicle.
      What the estimator checks
      The finish on each refinished panel, and finish time on the estimate.
    14. Test drive

      11 of 62 claims (18%)

      Too few of the 11 findings carried a dollar figure for a median.

      About Test drive: what it is, what to check
      What it is
      A test drive confirms the vehicle drives straight and its systems work after the repair.
      What the estimator checks
      Whether the repair touched systems that need a road test to verify.

    Each finding counts once, under the first type its title matches. Paint materials and diminished value came up on fewer than 10 claims and are left out. The sample is the same one Claimory's methodology page measures, with its limits: shops chose which claims to audit, and most audits ran before Claim Audit started dropping findings the estimate already carries.

    Questions about these findings

    Why do insurance estimates for collision repair come up short?

    Claimory's Claim Audit data shows where collision repair estimates come up short most often. Across 62 claims at 25 collision repair shops, audited from January 23 to October 30, 2026, Claim Audit flagged ADAS calibration on 42 claims, OEM parts or OEM repair procedures on 38 and pre-repair or post-repair scans on 34. Labor or materials rates below the shop's posted rate were flagged on 27 claims.

    Is a Claim Audit finding money the shop is owed?

    No. A Claim Audit finding is flagged, not collected. The carrier still decides each line, and some findings are items the estimator would have added at teardown anyway. The estimator checks every finding against the car before it goes on a supplement.

    How did Claimory group Claim Audit findings into types?

    Each finding was given one type from keywords in its title, and the first match won, so a weld-through primer finding that also mentions corrosion counts once, as weld-through primer. Types found on fewer than 10 of the 62 claims are left out, and a type's median dollar figure is shown only when at least 10 of its findings carried a dollar figure.

    Does Claimory publish a carrier approval rate for these items?

    No. Collision shops have logged too few carrier decisions in Claimory to publish an approval rate, and a rate built on a handful of decisions would mislead a shop.

    Run a Claim Audit on your own estimates

    The 14-day Claimory free trial needs no credit card and includes 3 Claim Audits. See how Claim Audit checks a collision repair estimate.

    Start Free 14-Day Trial

    No credit card. Works with CCC ONE and Mitchell.